Skip to main content
AlaskaLawHelp.org
 
Helping Alaskans find answers to their legal problems
 
 
 
 
Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Tribal Court
by: Alaska Legal Services Corporation   LSC LOGO
Q.

What kinds of cases get filed in tribal court?

A.

Most tribal court cases are about protecting children, about child custody, about adoption, or about inheritance. In at least one village there have been tribal court cases about who should control clan property. In at least one other village there have been tribal court cases about banishing a tribal member from the village. Each tribe is a separate government, so each tribe decides whether to have a tribal court and, if so, what kinds of cases to take.

Q.

Are there any kinds of cases that do NOT belong in tribal court?

A.

If a case is between two non-members of the tribe, it probably should not be in tribal court. If a tribe charges you with a crime, you should talk with a lawyer who knows "Indian law" about whether Alaskan tribes can charge people with crimes. (For example, it may depend on whether the alleged crime took place on tribal land or on BIA-restricted property.)

Q.

What happens in a custody case if I am a member of the tribe but the mother of our children isn?t?

A.

If the tribe is willing to consider the case, and the mother agrees that the case can be heard in tribal court, then everything should be OK. If the mother objects to having the case heard in tribal court, there is a complicated legal problem. Our best guess is that the tribe CAN hear the case if, but only if, the children are members of the tribe or eligible for membership.

Q.

Which tribe should handle a custody case if I am a member of one tribe but the father of our children is a member of another tribe?

A.

If the children are members of one tribe but not of the other tribe, it?s easy: the children?s tribe is the tribe that should be handling the case. If the children are members of both tribes, or if they are eligible for membership in both tribes, you should ask the tribal courts to talk with each other to see who should decide the case, or perhaps ask them to decide the case by acting jointly.

Q.

How can I find out how to file a case in tribal court?

A.

Talk with the tribal court clerk, or, if there is no tribal court clerk, the tribal official who handles tribal court cases.

Q.

How can I find out if a case has been filed against me in tribal court?

A.

Usually, you will get a notice from the tribal court (often called a summons), telling you that a case has been filed and what you have to do to respond. The tribal court clerk should also be able to tell you if a case has been filed.

Q.

What happens if there is already a case in state court?

A.

If you would rather have the case in state court than in tribal court, you should ask the tribal court to dismiss its case. If you would rather have the case in tribal court than in state court, you could ask the state court to transfer its case to the tribal court.

Q.

Where can I find the tribal court rules?

A.

Some tribal courts have written rules, and other tribal courts don?t. The tribal court clerk can tell you whether there are written rules and arrange for you to get copies.

Q.

Where can I find tribal laws and ordinances?

A.

Copies of laws and ordinances should be available at the tribal office. If you are looking for a copy of a tribe?s Constitution, this should be available from the tribe, and a copy should also be on file at the BIA.

Q.

Who are the tribal court judges?

A.

The tribal court judges are usually people in the community asked by the tribe to serve as judges. Sometimes a tribe will ask someone from outside the village to serve as a judge, particularly if everyone in the village is involved in a case and people might be worried that judges from the village could not be fair. You can find out from the tribal court clerk who the judges will be in your case. If you think that one or more of the judges could not be fair in your case, you should make a request in writing asking that person not to serve as a judge in your case.

Q.

Does the tribal court have to be separate from the tribal council?

A.

No. However, if the tribe is itself one of the parties to a case, there could be an argument that it would not be fair for Council members to serve as judges in the case.

Q.

Do I have a right to a court-appointed lawyer?

A.

Not unless the tribal court rules say that you do.

Q.

Can I hire a lawyer and have the lawyer represent me in the case?

A.

Probably, although it depends on the tribal court and on the kind of case. Some tribes would like people to speak for themselves at hearings and not speak through lawyers, although a lawyer can help someone prepare for a hearing. Some tribes will not allow lawyers to represent people at a hearing unless the lawyer is a member of the "Bar" of the tribal court. The lawyer can find out from the tribal court clerk how to become a member of the Bar. If you think a tribe is wrong in insisting that you speak for yourself and not through a lawyer, you should talk with a lawyer about whether you might have a Constitutional right to have a lawyer represent you.

Q.

Are tribal court hearings public or private?

A.

It depends on the tribe, and it depends on what kind of hearing it is. In state court, for example, hearings about protecting children are private, but hearings about child custody between parents are public.

Q.

Can I call anyone I want as a witness?

A.

Probably - it depends on the tribal court and the kind of case - but the witness?s testimony needs to be relevant to the case. If it is not, the tribal court can decide not to listen to it.

Q.

Can I get the tribal court to subpoena witnesses to come to court?

A.

It depends on the tribal court and the kind of case. If you are worried that a witness will not come to court unless there is a subpoena, you should fill out a subpoena for the court clerk?s signature and see what happens.

Q.

Can I have a jury trial?

A.

Probably not, unless the tribal court rules provide for one. Most of the kinds of cases tribal courts handle - child protective cases, custody cases, adoption cases, inheritance cases - are cases which would not have jury trials if they were in state court.

Q.

Does there have to be a tape recording of what happens at a tribal court hearing?

A.

Not necessarily, unless the tribal court rules say so; if they do, there should be a tape recording. If you would like to have a tape recording for yourself, it should generally be possible to bring your own tape recorder to the hearing or make arrangements with the tribal court clerk to get a copy of the tribal court?s recording.

Q.

Will there be a written decision?

A.

If the tribal court is going to direct people to do something, its instructions are usually in writing. Sometimes the judges explain things orally to the parties

Q.

If I don?t like the tribal court?s judgment, can I appeal?

A.

Many tribal courts have rules about where an appeal should go - to a separate appeals court, for example, or from the tribal court to the tribal Council. Some tribes do not have rules showing how to appeal. There is a legal argument that tribes have to allow for an appeal - somewhere and somehow - but it is not 100% clear that this is true.

Q.

If I don?t like the tribal court?s judgment, can I go to state court?

A.

The Alaska Supreme Court says NO - provided that the case is a case that belongs in tribal court and the tribal court proceedings were fair.

Q.

If I don?t like the tribal court?s judgment, can I go to federal court?

A.

Probably not. There may be an argument in a case involving children that a tribal court?s custody order is putting the child in tribal custody, so that you could try to get into federal court through "habeas corpus." There may also be an argument, if a tribe has banished you from the village, that this is close enough to a criminal case that you should be able to get into federal court, also through "habeas corpus."

Q.

How can I find out more about what tribal courts do?

A.

Tanana Chiefs Conference has published a very good Manual for Tribal Courts that explains what some tribal courts do - mostly in the Interior.

Q.
A.
Links:  Tribal Court Information Clearinghouse
  Search
   Tips for Successful Searching
Find Legal Help On Tribal Government & Tribal Courts
Related Resources
Directory of Federally Recognized Alaska Tribes (Separate Website)
By: American Indian Heritage Foundation
Native American Rights Fund (Separate Website)
By: Native American Rights Fund
Alaska Native Organizations (Separate Website)
By: Alaska Native Resources
more...
Last Reviewed On: 07/27/05
 
Information Not Legal Advice. This web site has been prepared for general information purposes only. The information on this web site is not legal advice. Legal advice is dependent upon the specific circumstances of each situation. Also, the law may vary from state to state, so that some information in this web site may not be correct for your jurisdiction. Finally, the information contained in this web site is not guaranteed to be up to date. Therefore, the information contained in this web site cannot replace the advice of competent legal counsel licensed in your state.

Lawyer Advertising. In some jurisdictions this web site may be considered lawyer advertising. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. Any listing of an attorney does not constitute a recommendation of the attorney. Before hiring any attorney, you should investigate the attorney's reputation and qualifications.

Links. This web site contains links to other resources on the Internet. Those links are provided as citations and aids to help you identify and locate other Internet resources that may be of interest, and are not intended to state or imply that we sponsor or are affiliated or associated with the persons or entities who created such site, nor are the links intended to state or imply that we are legally authorized to use any trade name, registered trademark, logo, legal or official seal, or copyrighted symbol that may be reflected in the links.

E-mail. Viewing this web site, or transmitting an e-mail message to Alaska Legal Services Corporation through this Web site, does not create an attorney-client relationship between Alaska Legal Services Corporation and you. Sending e-mail to an attorney mentioned in this site does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the attorney. Unless you are already a client of the attorney, your e-mail may not be protected by the attorney-client privilege. Moreover, unless it is encrypted, e-mail can be intercepted by persons other than the recipient. Deadlines are extremely important in most legal matters. You may lose important legal rights if you do not hire an attorney immediately to advise you. Many people do not check their e-mail daily, and some attorneys do not respond to unsolicited e-mail from non-clients.

 
  Powered by ProBono.Net

AlaskaLawHelp is a project of Alaska Legal Services Corporation in collaboration with community partners and advocacy groups, Pro Bono Net, and the Legal Services Corporation. Click here to fill out a user survey.

Legal Services Corporation    
 
  © 2001 - 2008, Pro Bono Net, All Rights Reserved

Bobby WorldWide Approved 508 Level A conformance icon, W3C-WAI Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 1.0